Thursday, August 09, 2012

Protect Malaysia’s Internet Freedom: STOP 114A

How 114A Evidence Act will affect you? 

I am not a lawyer, but I assume the following scenarios are possible

  • Someone post some defamatory comment on your blog or Facebook wall/timeline, you are in trouble with the law (guilty until proven innocent)
  • Someone hacked into your email, Google, Twitter or Facebook account and start posting some bad stuff, you are in trouble (guilty until proven innocent)
  • Someone use your computer or share/steal your Internet connection to do some bad stuff, you are in trouble (guilty until proven innocent)
  • Some post some bad stuff on your favorite blog, forum and website, the website could potentially be prosecuted and shutdown  (guilty until proven innocent).

What the consequences?

In order to protect oneself from getting into trouble with the law

  • User would withhold from posting “criticism” comment against the government or corrupted parties, afraid being prosecuted under the new law (guilty until proven innocent)
  • Website, Facebook and Blog owner would need to filter and moderate every comments (it could mean spending hours filtering through hundreds or thousands of comments everyday), and some might choose to disable commend or feedback due to the lack of manpower and time.
  • People who are not too IT-savvy (could be our parents and family) suffer the high risk of online identity theft (someone stole their email or Facebook password to do bad stuff) or stolen Wifi password could suffer the consequences of others’ irresponsible action.

“Guilty until proven innocent” is an act of laziness and irresponsibility meant to intimidate and prevent the public from using the Internet as the platform for freedom of speech and expressions.


What is 114A Evidence Act?

If an online post is traced back to your username and is considered seditious or defamatory by the government, you are guilty until proven innocent.

(1) If your name, photograph or pseudonym appears in a publication, which depicts yourself to have some connection with the publication, either you as the owner, editor or etc., you are presumed to have published or re–published the contents of the publication;

(2) If a publication originates from a network service that you have registered and subscribed to, you are presumed to have published or re-published the contents of the publication; or

(3) If a publication originates from a computer which you have custody or control on it, you are presumed to have published or re-published the contents of the publication

What are the problems?

i) It presumes guilt rather than innocence, which contradicts the basis of many justice systems.

ii) It makes Internet intermediaries–parties that provide online community forums, blogging and hosting services–liable for content that is published through their services. This can result in the removal of comment functions, which has a huge impact on the interactive nature of online media favoured by Malaysians.

iii) It threatens freedom of expression online through fear. It also reduces the spaces for posting legitimate comments and opinions.

iv) It allows hackers and cyber criminals to be free by making the person whose account/computer is hacked liable for any content/data which might have changed.

v) It reduces opportunities to be anonymous online which is crucial in promoting a free and open Internet.

vi) It is a bad law passed in haste and does not take into account public interest and participation.

Support Internet Blackout Day (14 August 2012)


  • Stop Section 114A Evidence Act
  • Protect Internet Freedom
  • Say No to "Guilty until proven Innocent"

Sources


8 comments:

tina said...

Well, the Evidence Act might help lower the cases on identity theft, hacking and other similar activities online. However, it is also a subtle way of stopping activists, whether in the streets or on the web, from speaking up against the unpleasant activities that Malaysian government is doing.

d_luaz said...

Obviously, the act could be more "refined".

sharetipsinfo said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anuska JAIN said...

In that situation you have to take the help of the companies and also complete the tasks soon enough. Bangalore Packers and Movers
Hyderabad Packers and Movers
Mumbai Packers and Movers
Pune Packers and Movers

Anuska JAIN said...

They have got the fun and also they gather the costs and the obligations without any wait. Chennai Packers and Movers
Delhi Packers and Movers
Gurgaon Packers and Movers
Noida Packers and Movers

Rupali sharma said...

such a nice blog i really appreciated thanks.
Escorts in bhiwadi
Escorts in sikanderpur
Escorts in mahipalpur

Aayush Jangra said...

RelocateServices.in
Packers and Movers in Bangalore
Packers and Movers in Delhi
Packers and Movers in Jaipur
Packers and Movers in Pune
Packers and Movers in Mumbai
Packers and Movers in Hyderabad
Packers and Movers in Chennai

narendra durbakula said...

Have you planned to move to Hyderabad? But, how confused will you manage and organize everything in order to move your goods to a new

destination safely? There is a simple solution available to this confusion and it is Packers and Movers Hyderabad. By walking to the

professionals, you can be stress-free when it comes to the safe movement of your goods.

packers and movers in hyderabad
packers and movers hyderabad
packers and movers kondapur